- Extra: “Andrew’s Odyssey”
February 17, 2018
Andrew manages to run out of gas, forget the pin code he's been using for years, get stuck in the middle of traffic, and sell a cellphone to a stranger - all before arriving late to record the show. We also discuss how to properly divide the blame in an affair.
- Episode 145: “Cringe”
February 8, 2018
Mat hides a super-secret bottle in his closet, Dan watches crime from a distance, Andrew deliberately taunts with emojis, and Mélissa mixes alcohol with food coloring and milk.
- Special: “Scrooge Hard”
December 31, 2017
Mat, Dan, Andrew and Mélissa can't seem to get along in this explosive, ghost-filled, time-bending holiday special! Merry Christmas and Happy New Year!
- Episode 144: “Barbecue”
December 2, 2017
Dan is the manliest of men, Mélissa doesn't understand BBQ sauce, Andrew lies to nurses, and Mat calls his stepdad Ben to hear about all his barbecue mishaps.
- Episode 143: “Paraplegic”
November 24, 2017
Mat uses an unorthodox method to get out of a sticky situation, Andrew stands up for wheelchair puns, Dan gets complimented by multiple voicemail callers, and Mélissa teaches us how to use tampons.
- Special: “This is Mad Libs” (song only)
November 15, 2017
The "This Is Mad Libs" song all by itself, without any extra commentary.
- Special: “This is Mad Libs”
November 15, 2017
This is a project Mat has had on the go for the last year, off and on. Today, the gang picks silly adjectives, verbs, and nouns, then jams them into a classic Halloween song.
- Special: “The Tale of the Earwig”
November 11, 2017
It's Andrew's turn to read a spooky story. Can he make his way into the club using a story he found on the same website as Mat?
- Episode 142: “Horror”
October 31, 2017
Dan dies in a horrible circus accident, Mat gives a brief history lesson on the Friday the 13th movies, Andrew confuses 127 Hours with 28 Days Later, and Mélissa's parents forbid her from gettin' spooked.
- Special: “The Tale of the A Message From Your Personal Demons”
October 28, 2017
This is Mélissa's first time joining in on the spooky story fun, and she manages to pick the darkest story of all.